Scenic Mackinac Island bike trail along Lake Huron with horse-drawn carriage and walking path, summer exploration on car-free island

Best Ways to Explore Mackinac Island: Bike Rentals, Horse-Drawn Carriages & Walking Tours

Mackinac Island is a rare gem in today’s fast-paced world. Located in Northern Michigan’s Lake Huron, this serene, car-free island has preserved a sense of timeless wonder and natural beauty unlike anywhere else in the United States. But with no cars allowed, the question arises for many travelers: what is the best way to explore Mackinac Island?

Whether you’re visiting for the day or enjoying a luxurious escape at The Inn at Stonecliffe, the answer lies in three unforgettable, immersive experiences—bike rentals, horse-drawn carriages, and walking tours. Each method offers a unique perspective and pace to soak in the island’s charm, history, and iconic landscapes. This guide will help you decide how to discover Mackinac Island’s magic, from scenic shorelines to forest trails and hidden historic gems.

Table of Contents

  1. Why Mackinac Island Is Car-Free

  2. Overview: Getting Around the Island

  3. Biking Mackinac Island: Freedom on Two Wheels

    • Where to Rent Bikes

    • Bike Rental Prices and Types

    • Scenic Biking Routes and Trails

    • Family-Friendly Bike Ideas

  4. Horse-Drawn Carriage Tours: A Nod to the Past

    • Narrated vs. Private Carriage Rides

    • Booking Tips and Tour Options

    • What You’ll See on a Carriage Tour

  5. Walking Mackinac Island: Hidden Gems on Foot

    • Top Walking Paths and Trails

    • Self-Guided and Historical Walking Tours

    • Nature Walks Near The Inn at Stonecliffe

  6. Bike vs. Carriage vs. Walking: Which Is Best for You?

  7. Tips for Planning Your Island Exploration

  8. Pair Your Adventure with the Perfect Stay at The Inn at Stonecliffe

  9. Frequently Asked Questions

  10. Final Thoughts: See the Island Your Way

1. Why Mackinac Island Is Car-Free

One of the most frequently asked questions is: Why are there no cars on Mackinac Island? The answer ties into the island’s preservation of peace, history, and natural ambiance. Since 1898, motor vehicles have been banned to maintain quiet streets, protect the environment, and preserve the island’s historic character. Instead of traffic and exhaust, you'll hear the gentle clip-clop of horses and the hum of bicycle tires along scenic trails.

This unique feature not only elevates the charm of the island but also makes it one of the most immersive slow-travel destinations in America.

2. Overview: Getting Around the Island

When you arrive on Mackinac Island—by ferry, private boat, or even seaplane—you’ll find yourself stepping back in time. Without cars, all exploration happens through more intentional, immersive ways:

  • Bicycles – Rent one and ride the entire 8.2-mile shoreline loop or explore deeper into the island’s interior.

  • Horse-Drawn Carriages – Choose from group tours or private rides for a narrated journey through landmarks and nature.

  • Walking – Stroll at your own pace along historic streets, forest trails, and waterfront boardwalks.

Each experience offers something unique—and combining all three during your stay is a popular option for travelers who want the full Mackinac Island experience.

3. Biking Mackinac Island: Freedom on Two Wheels

Where to Rent Bikes on Mackinac Island

Biking is the most popular way to explore Mackinac Island, and with good reason. The island’s flat perimeter roads, tree-lined trails, and zero car traffic make for a leisurely ride, whether you’re alone or with the whole family.

Top bike rental providers include:

  • Mackinac Island Bike Shop

  • Ryba’s Bike Rentals

  • Island House Bike Rentals

  • Mission Point Bike Rentals

Many hotels, including The Inn at Stonecliffe, also offer on-site bike rental or can assist with arrangements.

Bike Rental Prices and Types

Bike rental prices vary depending on the season and the type of bike, but expect:

  • Single-speed cruiser: $10–$15/hour

  • Tandem bike: $20–$30/hour

  • Electric bike (E-bike): $25–$35/hour (note: not all areas allow e-bikes)

  • Kids bikes and trailers also available

Daily rentals provide better value, and many shops offer helmets, baskets, and maps.

Scenic Biking Routes and Trails

  • M-185 (Shoreline Loop): An 8.2-mile paved path that circles the entire island with constant Lake Huron views. A must-do!

  • Leslie Avenue to Arch Rock: A forested path with a gentle climb to one of the island’s most iconic views.

  • Sugar Loaf and Fort Holmes Trail: For those seeking adventure, these trails go uphill but reward riders with historic sites and photo-worthy vistas.

Family-Friendly Biking Ideas

  • Add a tagalong trailer or toddler seat to your rental.

  • Take breaks at British Landing or the Mackinac Island Butterfly House.

  • Stop for a picnic near Great Turtle Park or on the lawn of The Inn at Stonecliffe.

4. Horse-Drawn Carriage Tours: A Nod to the Past

Narrated vs. Private Carriage Rides

For a truly authentic Mackinac experience, hop aboard a horse-drawn carriage. You’ll travel at a graceful pace while learning the island’s stories from your driver-guide.

Narrated Group Tours (via Mackinac Island Carriage Tours):

  • Depart regularly from downtown

  • Last approximately 1 hour 45 minutes

  • Stop at Surrey Hills, Arch Rock, and Fort Mackinac

Private Carriage Tours:

  • Customize your route

  • Ideal for romantic rides or small families

  • Book in advance—especially in summer

Booking Tips and Tour Options

  • Buy tickets early, especially on weekends

  • Private carriages book up quickly—reserve days ahead

  • Prices vary by length and size of group, starting around $90

What You’ll See on a Carriage Tour

  • Arch Rock (iconic natural limestone arch)

  • Governor’s Residence

  • Skull Cave

  • Mission Church

  • The Grand Hotel and West Bluff mansions

Many visitors combine a carriage ride with a stop at The Inn at Stonecliffe for lunch or an afternoon cocktail in our historic setting.

5. Walking Mackinac Island: Hidden Gems on Foot

Top Walking Paths and Trails

Some of the best discoveries on Mackinac Island are made on foot.

  • Boardwalk along the west shore: Ideal for sunset strolls

  • Tranquil Bluff Trail: Overlooks Lake Huron with dense forest scenery

  • Fort Holmes Trail: Steep but rewarding for panoramic views

Self-Guided and Historical Walking Tours

Pick up a map from the Visitor’s Center or download an app to guide you past:

  • Historic downtown buildings

  • Ste. Anne’s Church

  • Marquette Park

  • Cemeteries with rich Civil War history

  • Native American cultural markers

Nature Walks Near The Inn at Stonecliffe

Guests staying at The Inn at Stonecliffe enjoy direct access to peaceful walking paths that wind through wooded groves and meadows. Unlike the busier downtown areas, this part of the island offers quiet serenity and rare views of the Mackinac Bridge.

6. Bike vs. Carriage vs. Walking: Which Is Best for You?

Mode of Travel Best For Pros Considerations
Bike Active travelers, full island loop Fast, flexible, scenic May require strength for uphill trails
Carriage Couples, families, history lovers Relaxed pace, narrated More expensive, fixed routes
Walking Slow travelers, photographers Free, intimate, peaceful Limited range per day

Best strategy: Combine all three during a 2- or 3-day stay.

7. Tips for Planning Your Island Exploration

  • Start early: Mornings are less crowded.

  • Dress in layers: Weather shifts quickly near Lake Huron.

  • Bring water and sunscreen

  • Pack light: Especially if biking or walking long distances.

  • Stay overnight: Day-trippers miss the quiet beauty of early morning and dusk.

8. Pair Your Adventure with the Perfect Stay at The Inn at Stonecliffe

Set atop the island’s west bluff with views of the Mackinac Bridge and surrounding water, The Inn at Stonecliffe is ideally located for guests who want both exploration and retreat.

Why Stonecliffe is Perfect for Exploring the Island:

  • Easy access to bike paths and walking trails

  • Quiet location away from downtown crowds

  • Complimentary concierge assistance for booking bike rentals and carriage tours

  • On-site dining and weekly programming for guests

  • Historic charm meets modern luxury

After a day of adventure, unwind with a glass of wine on our lawn, take in the sunset, and reflect on the day’s discoveries.

9. Frequently Asked Questions

How long does it take to bike around Mackinac Island?
Roughly 1.5 to 2 hours without stops, but many take 3–4 hours with scenic breaks and photo ops.

Are electric bikes allowed on Mackinac Island?
Class 1 e-bikes are permitted for individuals with mobility limitations and must be approved in advance.

Can I bring my own bike to Mackinac Island?
Yes. Ferries accommodate personal bikes for a small fee.

Do I need to reserve a carriage tour in advance?
Private carriages: yes. Group tours: not always, but recommended during peak season.

Is Mackinac Island walkable?
Absolutely. With flat downtown streets and well-marked trails, it’s perfect for walking tours.

10. Final Thoughts: See the Island Your Way

Mackinac Island’s charm is best experienced at your own pace—whether you’re cruising on a bike, rolling along in a horse-drawn carriage, or strolling through quiet forest paths. Each mode of transportation offers its own window into the soul of the island.

When you stay at The Inn at Stonecliffe, you’re not just choosing a place to sleep—you’re choosing a more serene, elevated way to experience Mackinac Island. Let your adventure begin here.

Read other posts