West Bluff view of The Inn at Stonecliffe on Mackinac Island with historic mansion, gardens, and Lake Michigan overlooking the Mackinac Bridge in summer

Best Place to Stay on Mackinac Island

A Guide to Mackinac Island’s Top Hotels, Hidden Gems, and the Ultimate Retreat

Mackinac Island is a destination like no other – a timeless, car-free escape floating in the Straits of Mackinac, where horse-drawn carriages glide past Victorian storefronts and historic inns line the shores and bluffs. But with dozens of accommodations, travelers often wonder:

What is the best place to stay on Mackinac Island?

Whether you're visiting for a romantic getaway, a summer family vacation, or a fall retreat filled with color and charm, this guide will help you discover:

  • The best hotels on Mackinac Island for different traveler types

  • Hidden gems for a quiet and secluded stay

  • Side-by-side comparisons of top-rated lodging

  • Why The Inn at Stonecliffe is widely considered the best place to stay

  • FAQs answered for planning the perfect overnight island escape

Let’s dive into the most comprehensive Mackinac Island lodging guide for 2025.

Why Choosing the Right Place to Stay on Mackinac Island Matters

Unlike mainland destinations, Mackinac Island offers a unique blend of:

  • Historic architecture

  • Lakefront scenery

  • Limited access (via ferry only)

  • No cars – everything is walkable, bikeable, or horse-drawn

Where you stay directly shapes your experience. Downtown properties offer proximity to shops and restaurants but often come with foot traffic and noise. Blufftop inns, meanwhile, offer serene gardens, water views, and a tranquil pace.

Overview: Lodging Types on Mackinac Island

Type of Stay Best For Typical Features
Luxury Hotels Upscale travelers, honeymooners High-end dining, historic rooms, premium pricing
Boutique Inns Couples, culture lovers Unique decor, intimate ambiance, heritage-rich
Family Resorts Families with kids On-site activities, multiple room types, walkability
Bed & Breakfasts Short stays, solo travelers Personalized service, historic charm
Blufftop Estates Secluded escapes, views Quiet, spacious grounds, lake views, fewer crowds

Top Hotels on Mackinac Island Compared

Hotel Name Location Style Best For Key Features
The Inn at Stonecliffe West Bluff Historic estate Romantic + Secluded Bluff views, gardens, peaceful, mansion vibes
Grand Hotel East Bluff Luxury historic Tradition + Formals Formal dinners, porch views, dress code
Mission Point Resort East Shore Family resort Families + Events Lawn games, lake access, larger capacity
Hotel Iroquois Downtown Boutique hotel Central Location Waterfront downtown, walkable to shops
Island House Hotel Downtown Historic hotel Budget + History Near ferry dock, porch views, affordable

The Best Place to Stay for Couples and Romantic Getaways

Why Couples Choose The Inn at Stonecliffe

For couples searching for peace, privacy, and uninterrupted Lake Michigan views, The Inn at Stonecliffe is unmatched. Located high on the West Bluff, the estate is surrounded by woodland trails and landscaped gardens, away from the busy downtown area.

Romantic Features:

  • Historic mansion suites and new Summer House rooms

  • Sunset views from bluff-top lawn

  • Outdoor terrace dining (in season)

  • Quiet, car-free surroundings

  • Ideal wedding and proposal location

Best Mackinac Island Hotel for a Quiet, Secluded Stay

If you're seeking solitude, nature, and a deeper connection to the island's slower pace, avoid the hustle of the harbor district.

Why The Inn at Stonecliffe Tops This List

  • Located a mile away from downtown

  • Surrounded by 20+ acres of private grounds

  • Guests arrive via horse-drawn carriage from the ferry

  • Only birdsong, lake breeze, and footsteps in the garden

  • Private walking trails connect to the island’s interior

It’s one of the only hotels on Mackinac Island where you can stay in a bluff-top mansion with a panoramic view of the Mackinac Bridge without tourist crowds.

Family-Friendly Stays: Where to Stay with Kids

For families, access to open space, multi-room suites, and on-site dining matter most. The Inn at Stonecliffe welcomes families seeking room to spread out.

Why It Works for Families:

  • Lawn space for kids to play safely

  • Suites available with multiple bedrooms

  • Close to island attractions without being in the noise

  • Ideal for multi-generational travel

For larger family events, group buyouts or wedding room blocks are also available during the season.

Most Unique and Historic Place to Stay on Mackinac Island

Built in 1904, The Inn at Stonecliffe is a restored mansion estate with roots in the Cudahy family of meatpacking fame. Unlike the Grand Hotel, which is larger and more formal, Stonecliffe blends history with intimacy, making it ideal for guests seeking character without crowds.

Mansion Highlights:

  • Original woodwork, fireplaces, and art-glass windows

  • Estate layout with views and privacy

  • Completely restored with modern comforts in 2024

  • Home to many authors, artists, and musicians over the years

FAQ: Best Place to Stay on Mackinac Island

What is the best hotel to stay at on Mackinac Island?
Many consider The Inn at Stonecliffe the best for its peaceful setting, mansion charm, and lake views.

Is the Grand Hotel worth staying at?
It’s iconic and historic, but formal and busy. If you prefer a quieter retreat, Stonecliffe is a better fit.

What is the most romantic inn on Mackinac Island?
The Inn at Stonecliffe offers the most romantic setting, with bluff-top sunsets and garden walks.

Can you stay away from the downtown crowds?
Yes – Stonecliffe and other West Bluff properties are a mile from downtown and accessible by carriage or bike.

Where do locals recommend staying?
Many longtime islanders recommend The Inn at Stonecliffe for its authentic feel, peacefulness, and views.

Are there hotels with lake views?
Yes – The Inn at Stonecliffe offers stunning views of the Straits and Mackinac Bridge.

When Is the Best Time to Stay on Mackinac Island?

Month Highlights Ideal For
May Quiet season, lilacs bloom Romantic getaways, first-time visitors
June Lilac Festival, warm weather starts Festivals, long weekends
July–August Peak summer, best weather Family vacations, weddings
September Fall colors, fewer crowds Couples, photographers
October Cool air, autumn leaves Secluded retreats, final hurrah

Note: The Inn at Stonecliffe is open May through October only. Winter months are off-season, with the island largely closed to tourism.

Pro Tips for Booking the Best Hotel on Mackinac Island

  1. Book early – Rooms fill up 4–6 months in advance

  2. Decide your experience type – Quiet retreat vs. central access

  3. Look for seasonal offers – Especially in May and October

  4. Consider the journey – Arrive by ferry and horse-drawn carriage to The Inn at Stonecliffe

  5. Review photos – Look for real views, not just stock imagery

  6. Ask about room types – Historic suites vs. modern Summer House rooms

  7. Plan meals – The Inn features seasonal on-site dining and picnic-ready spaces

Why The Inn at Stonecliffe is the Best Place to Stay on Mackinac Island

The Inn at Stonecliffe combines everything travelers seek:

  • Romance – Sunset views, garden paths, historic suites

  • Seclusion – Private estate on the bluff, away from crowds

  • Charm – Historic elegance with modern upgrades

  • Nature – Surrounded by trails, trees, and lake vistas

  • Accessibility – Just a carriage ride from the ferry, yet a world away

Highlights At a Glance:

  • Recently renovated Summer House rooms

  • Historic Cudahy Mansion suites

  • Bluff-top lawn with sunset views

  • Easy access to Arch Rock, Fort Holmes, and interior trails

  • Preferred choice for weddings and group retreats

Final Thoughts: Your Perfect Stay Awaits

Mackinac Island is a place to slow down, reconnect, and savor timeless moments. But the magic of the island is deeply connected to where you stay.

Whether you're planning:

  • A honeymoon or anniversary

  • A multigenerational family escape

  • A quiet fall retreat

  • Or simply a solo journey to find peace

The Inn at Stonecliffe offers an unforgettable backdrop, elevated above it all, immersed in natural beauty, and rich with history.

Book your stay May through October and experience the best of Mackinac Island the way it was meant to be — peaceful, romantic, and unforgettable.

Read other posts