Famous Shipwrecks in the Great Lakes: Legends, History, and Haunting Tales

The Depths of Tragedy: Why the Great Lakes Are Known as North America’s Shipwreck Graveyard

The Great Lakes – Superior, Michigan, Huron, Erie, and Ontario – together form the largest group of freshwater lakes on Earth. While these waters appear serene from shorelines, they conceal a stormy and perilous legacy. With over 6,000 documented shipwrecks, the Great Lakes have earned a reputation as one of the most dangerous and mysterious bodies of water for maritime travel.

The combination of volatile storms, hidden shoals, fog, frigid waters, and the sheer size of the lakes has led to centuries of maritime disasters – from commercial freighters and passenger steamships to schooners and ghost ships. This guide explores the most famous shipwrecks in the Great Lakes, along with how to visit, learn, and reflect on these aquatic time capsules.

How Many Shipwrecks Are in the Great Lakes?

According to estimates from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) and maritime heritage researchers:

• Total shipwrecks: 6,000+ documented

• Estimated undiscovered wrecks: 2,000 to 3,000

• Fatalities: Over 30,000 lives lost since the 1600s

Each Great Lake has its own share of legendary losses and preserved shipwrecks that offer insight into trade, immigration, industry, and exploration.

Most Famous Great Lakes Shipwrecks by Lake

Lake Superior

• SS Edmund Fitzgerald (1975): The most iconic Great Lakes wreck. Sank in a storm with all 29 crew lost.

• SS Kamloops (1927): Discovered in 1977, the wreck lies deep and is known for preserved human remains.

• The Bannockburn (1902): Nicknamed “The Flying Dutchman of the Great Lakes” – disappeared without a trace.

Lake Michigan

• SS Eastland (1915): Capsized while docked in Chicago – 844 lives lost, the deadliest Great Lakes disaster.

• Lady Elgin (1860): Collided in stormy waters – over 300 dead.

• Carl D. Bradley (1958): Broke in two during a storm, killing 33 of 35 crew.

Lake Huron

• SS Regina (1913): Lost in the “White Hurricane” of 1913, a storm that sank 12 ships.

• Daniel J. Morrell (1966): Broke apart mid-lake in a violent storm – only one survivor.

• W.C. Franz (1880s): Preserved wooden schooner near Thunder Bay.

Lake Erie

• SS G.P. Griffith (1850): Caught fire – over 280 lost.

• SS Marquette & Bessemer No. 2 (1909): Lost with 30+ crew – remains undiscovered.

• Lake Serpent (1829): Rediscovered after 190 years.

Lake Ontario

• SS Asia (1882): Sank with 85 lives lost – one of Ontario’s worst maritime disasters.

• HMS Ontario (1780): British warship lost in a gale – discovered in 2008.

• Hamilton and Scourge (1813): War of 1812 wrecks, preserved near Niagara.

Top 10 Most Famous Great Lakes Shipwrecks: Ranked

Rank	Ship Name	Lake	Year	Lives Lost	Cause
1	Edmund Fitzgerald	Superior	1975	29	Storm
2	Eastland	Michigan	1915	844	Capsized at dock
3	Lady Elgin	Michigan	1860	300+	Collision
4	Carl D. Bradley	Michigan	1958	33	Structural failure
5	Regina	Huron	1913	Unknown	Storm
6	Kamloops	Superior	1927	Unknown	Ice + Storm
7	Bannockburn	Superior	1902	All	Unknown
8	Asia	Ontario	1882	85+	Storm
9	G.P. Griffith	Erie	1850	280+	Fire
10	Daniel J. Morrell	Huron	1966	28	Structural + Storm

Why So Many Shipwrecks? Common Causes Across the Great Lakes

1. Sudden, Violent Storms

The Great Lakes are known for generating storms rivaling ocean hurricanes. The infamous “White Hurricane” of 1913 sank more than a dozen ships.

2. Poor Weather Forecasting (Pre-1950s)

Many ships sailed blind into storms before radar, satellite, or even barometric awareness.

3. Structural Failures

Older wooden ships and early steel freighters were prone to mid-lake fractures under wave pressure.

4. Navigational Errors

Rocky shoals, dense fog, and human error led to frequent groundings and collisions.

5. Icing and Freezing Conditions

Lake Superior and Huron were especially treacherous in shoulder seasons. Ice buildup increased the risk of sinking.

Are There Still Undiscovered Shipwrecks in the Great Lakes?

Yes. Researchers estimate 2,000+ shipwrecks remain undiscovered. New discoveries happen yearly due to:

• SONAR and underwater LIDAR

• NOAA expeditions

• Scuba diver reports

• Remote operated vehicle (ROV) mapping

Some of the most desired discoveries include:

• The Westmoreland (Lake Michigan – gold rumored aboard)

• Marquette & Bessemer No. 2 (Lake Erie)

• Le Griffon (Lake Michigan – 1679, the first Great Lakes shipwreck)

Visiting Great Lakes Shipwrecks: Museums, Dives, and Viewing Sites

Shipwreck Museums:

• Great Lakes Shipwreck Museum – Whitefish Point, Michigan (Edmund Fitzgerald artifacts)

• Great Lakes Maritime Heritage Center – Alpena, Michigan

• Wisconsin Maritime Museum – Manitowoc, Wisconsin

Best Shipwreck Diving Sites:

• Thunder Bay National Marine Sanctuary – Lake Huron, near Alpena

• Whitefish Point Underwater Preserve – Lake Superior

• Straits of Mackinac Shipwreck Preserve – Lake Michigan

Glass-Bottom Boat Tours:

• Munising, Michigan (Lake Superior) – Pictured Rocks area

• Charlevoix and Alpena (Lake Huron) – Shallow wreck viewing

Stonecliffe Guest Tip:

If you're staying at The Inn at Stonecliffe (May–October only), ask about guided history tours or visits to Shipwreck Museum exhibits at nearby ports. While Mackinac Island is not a diving destination, it is surrounded by shipwreck zones in the Straits.

Great Lakes Shipwrecks in Pop Culture and Lore

The Edmund Fitzgerald Ballad:

Made famous by Gordon Lightfoot’s 1976 hit, this folk song immortalized the tragedy and mystery of the Fitzgerald’s sinking.

Ghost Ships & Myths:

• The Flying Dutchman of Lake Superior (Bannockburn)

• The Le Griffon curse – believed to have vanished with French gold

• Phantom lights seen over wreck zones

Books and Documentaries:

• “Shipwrecks of the Great Lakes” – Dwight Boyer

• “The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald” – Frederick Stonehouse

• PBS Specials on Great Lakes diving and archaeology

FAQs About Great Lakes Shipwrecks

What is the most famous Great Lakes shipwreck?

The SS Edmund Fitzgerald is the most well-known. It sank in 1975 in Lake Superior and is still deeply studied and memorialized.

Which Great Lake has the most shipwrecks?

Lake Erie has the most due to its shallow depth and heavy 19th-century traffic, though Lake Superior has the most famous wrecks.

Can I dive to Great Lakes shipwrecks?

Yes. Certain wrecks in Lake Huron and Lake Michigan are accessible to certified divers. Conditions are cold and deep.

Are Great Lakes shipwrecks preserved?

Cold freshwater, low oxygen, and preservation efforts mean many wrecks are intact – even wooden vessels over 150 years old.

Are there ghost ships in the Great Lakes?

Legends abound. Ships like the Bannockburn and Le Griffon are the source of numerous maritime ghost stories.

Plan Your Visit to Michigan’s Maritime Heartland

The warm-weather season from May through October is the perfect window to explore Michigan's rich maritime history. Travelers can trace the path of shipping legends, visit Great Lakes museums, and enjoy beautiful island stays at Mackinac.

While The Inn at Stonecliffe is closed during winter, guests visiting between May and October can enjoy:

• Fresh island air and scenic views

• Access to mainland shipwreck museums

• Maritime-themed excursions and photo ops

Travel Suggestions:

• Base your trip at The Inn at Stonecliffe (open May–October)

• Take a ferry to Mackinac Island via Mackinaw City

• Plan a road trip to Alpena or Whitefish Point before or after your stay

Final Thoughts: Honoring History, Preserving Legacy

The shipwrecks of the Great Lakes are more than tragic stories – they are windows into the past, each wreck a chapter in the story of America’s inland seas. By learning their stories, visiting their resting places, and preserving their memories, travelers can connect deeply with the power and mystery of the water.

From the depths of Lake Superior to the museums along Lake Huron, the shipwreck legacy is one of courage, loss, and legend.

➡️ Plan Your Stay at The Inn at Stonecliffe

Read other posts