peaceful hidden trail biking path along Mackinac Island forest and Lake Huron for serene crowd-free exploration

How to Get Around Mackinac Island Without the Crowds: A Complete Guide by The Inn at Stonecliffe

Mackinac Island is one of the Midwest’s most beloved destinations — a picturesque island where horse-drawn carriages replace cars, Victorian charm infuses every street, and the waters of Lake Huron shimmer around every bend. But for travelers who value serenity as much as scenery, the island can feel a bit overwhelming during the busy summer months. Fortunately, there are plenty of ways to experience Mackinac Island without the crowds. At The Inn at Stonecliffe, we specialize in providing our guests with peaceful, exclusive experiences, and this guide shares all our best tips.

Why Mackinac Island Gets Crowded

Mackinac Island welcomes over one million visitors each year, with the bulk arriving between June and August. The car-free streets, iconic fudge shops, and historic landmarks are irresistible — and everyone wants to see them. Most visitors stay in the bustling downtown area, which is why finding ways to explore beyond the crowds becomes essential for a truly restorative experience.

At The Inn at Stonecliffe, our serene setting 1.7 miles from downtown already offers a respite from the noise. Here’s how you can extend that sense of exclusivity to your whole island adventure.

Best Times to Visit Mackinac Island for Fewer Crowds

Early Morning and Late Evening

Most day-trippers arrive around mid-morning and leave by late afternoon. That means the hours just after sunrise and just before sunset are the quietest times to explore.

Shoulder Seasons

Visiting in late spring (May to early June) or early fall (September through mid-October) can dramatically reduce crowds. These seasons bring cooler temperatures and vibrant colors — perfect for peaceful exploration.

Midweek

If possible, plan your stay for midweek rather than over a weekend. You’ll encounter far fewer visitors at every turn.

Where to Stay: Away from the Hustle

Choosing accommodations away from downtown is perhaps the single best decision you can make if you’re looking to avoid the crowds. The Inn at Stonecliffe is nestled on a bluff overlooking the Straits of Mackinac and Mackinac Bridge, offering a luxurious retreat surrounded by nature. Our fully renovated mansion rooms, Summer House rooms, and private cottages provide ample space and peace. With water-view balconies, curated décor, and on-site activities, you may not want to leave.

Ways to Get Around Mackinac Island Without the Crowds

Walking: Discover Hidden Trails

Walking remains the most peaceful way to explore the island — and it allows you to access spots that carriages and bikes can’t reach. Here are some recommended routes:

  • Boardwalk Stroll: Start at the west end of downtown and follow the boardwalk along the water toward the Mackinac Bridge. It’s a quiet stretch with scenic lake views.

  • Arch Rock via Forest Trails: Instead of following the main road to Arch Rock, take the forested paths through the interior. These shady trails see far less foot traffic.

  • British Landing and Beyond: Walk the perimeter road past British Landing, where the crowds thin out and the sound of waves accompanies you.

Biking: Beyond the Main Loop

Bikes are a quintessential way to see Mackinac, but most people stick to the 8.2-mile perimeter road. To avoid the crowds, consider these less-traveled routes:

  • The Tranquil Interior: From The Inn at Stonecliffe, pedal inland toward Skull Cave and Fort Holmes. These hills reward you with solitude and panoramic views.

  • Northwest Bluff Road: This scenic path climbs above the shoreline for a quiet ride through wooded bluffs.

  • Leslie Avenue & Annex Streets: These quiet residential streets near the west side of the island are perfect for a leisurely, crowd-free ride.

Pro Tip: Rent your bikes from The Inn at Stonecliffe to skip the busy downtown rental shops altogether.

Horse-Drawn Carriage: Private or After Hours

While carriage rides are iconic, the public tours can feel crowded and rushed. Instead, opt for a private carriage tour. These can be arranged through local stables and allow you to customize your route and pace.

Even better, book your carriage ride for early morning or evening when the streets are less busy and the lighting is magical.

Exploring Secret Spots

Many visitors never venture beyond the downtown shops and major landmarks. But Mackinac Island is full of hidden gems:

  • Anne’s Tablet: A tranquil overlook commemorating author Constance Fenimore Woolson.

  • Cemetery Road: A peaceful path lined with historic cemeteries and stunning views.

  • Crack-in-the-Island: A quiet, off-the-beaten-path geological curiosity.

  • Sunset Rock: A secluded west-facing bluff perfect for sunset.

These secret spots let you experience the island’s natural beauty without interruption.

Timing Your Exploration

Best Hours to Explore

  • 6:00–10:00 AM: Empty streets and soft morning light.

  • 4:00–8:00 PM: Day-trippers have departed, and the island regains its calm.

Worst Hours for Crowds

  • 10:30 AM–3:30 PM: Ferries deposit the bulk of visitors during these hours. Focus on enjoying The Inn at Stonecliffe’s amenities during this time.

Dining Without the Wait

Downtown restaurants fill quickly during peak hours. Guests at The Inn at Stonecliffe can enjoy private dining options, picnics, or reservations at our on-site venues. Alternatively, aim for early or late meal times downtown.

Picnicking is also a charming way to enjoy the island — pack a basket and find a quiet bluff or beach.

Why Choose The Inn at Stonecliffe?

Beyond its prime location away from the crowds, The Inn at Stonecliffe offers a holistic, high-end retreat where guests experience:

  • Two pools: one for families and another adults-only

  • Weekly guest programming including yoga, wine tastings, craft classes, and live music

  • Bike rentals and private dining

  • Fully renovated rooms and cottages with premium amenities

When you stay here, the exclusive atmosphere and attentive service let you truly unwind.

Tips for a Peaceful Visit

  1. Book Midweek: Rooms are more available, and attractions are less busy.

  2. Stay Overnight: You’ll enjoy the island at its quietest before and after the day-trippers.

  3. Plan Activities Strategically: Explore early or late; relax during the midday rush.

  4. Bring Comfortable Shoes: You’ll want to take advantage of the island’s beautiful walking paths.

  5. Pack Layers: Mornings and evenings are cooler, and layers let you stay comfortable.

FAQs

What is the least crowded time of day on Mackinac Island?

Early morning (6:00–9:00 AM) and late afternoon/evening (after 4:00 PM) are the least crowded times.

Are there areas of the island that stay quiet even during peak season?

Yes. The western bluff near The Inn at Stonecliffe, British Landing, and interior trails remain quiet even in summer.

Do I need to rent a bike downtown?

No. Guests at The Inn at Stonecliffe can rent bikes on-site to avoid downtown crowds.

Can I avoid the horse-drawn carriage tours?

Absolutely. You can walk, bike, or book a private carriage tour at quieter hours.

Sample Itinerary: A Day Without the Crowds

  • 6:30 AM: Sunrise walk to Sunset Rock

  • 8:00 AM: Breakfast at The Inn at Stonecliffe

  • 9:00 AM: Quiet bike ride through the interior to Arch Rock

  • 11:00 AM: Relax by the pool or enjoy a yoga class

  • 1:00 PM: Picnic lunch on a secluded bluff

  • 3:00 PM: Nap or spa time at the Inn

  • 4:30 PM: Private carriage ride through the island

  • 7:00 PM: Dinner at our private dining room

  • 8:30 PM: Sunset at British Landing

Final Thoughts

Mackinac Island’s charm shines brightest when you find its quiet corners and embrace its slower pace. By staying at The Inn at Stonecliffe and using these tips, you’ll discover a more authentic, serene side of the island — far from the crowds.

For more information, or to book your peaceful Mackinac Island retreat, visit The Inn at Stonecliffe.

Read other posts